Citi Blogs


Establishment of Bourgeois Neighborhood in the late 18th to early 20th Century Calcutta: Identity formation and construction of exclusive precincts

Urban History

cover banner
Housing Elitism

08-05-2024

The first decision of the partition in 1905, made by the colonial rulers for administrative convenience, marked the initial recognition of boundaries in Calcutta. Subsequently, these boundarieswithin Calcutta became evident as visible cracks in the fabric of the city. They are termed as 'surfacing' rather than 'emerging' due to the pre-existence of a well-established boundary within thecity, delineated by factors such as community, occupation, and economic status. Upon overlaying early maps of Calcutta, these boundaries are clearly discernible. Analogies to these boundariesare drawn using Western classical musical annotations.

After the Battle of Plassey in 1757, the area within the trench along the eastern edge of the city, known as the Maratha Ditch, was ceded to the company. The Circular Road was subsequentlyconstructed over the Maratha ditch, perpetuating a division within the city that persists to this day. Swati Chattopadhyay, in her book "Representing Calcutta," highlights that English visitors inthe late eighteenth and nineteenth centuries often described a division between a "white town" and a "black town." The former was characterised by fine rows of houses surrounding the Maidan,while the latter appeared to be situated beyond. Unlike in other colonial cities, the separation between the white and black towns in Calcutta was largely undefined, possibly due to the presence ofthe "grey town" and other settlements such as Chinese, Armenian, and Anglo-Indian communities.

Upon overlaying the boundaries of the white town as delineated by William Baillie, Lieutenant R.G. Wallace, and Orlich and Thornton, a clear north-south division emerges. The inherentvaluation of the white over the black by colonisers is akin to the hierarchy observed in Western musical notes, where white notes hold more significance than black notes, and no quavers or semi-quavers are assigned to white notes. Furthermore, the boundaries of the elite neighbourhoods culminate at the Maratha ditch like a perfect cadence, while the remaining areas form a deceptivecadence. Consequently, the essay underscores the intrinsic segregation in the formation of homogeneous neighbourhoods within the city, and the broader delineation of these clusters as theycorrespond to the "beyond."(1)

Creation of European identityThroughout history, Europeans have constructed their identity by perpetuating the process of "othering" native populations. While it can be acknowledged that distinctions between groups havealways existed, the pivotal difference emerges when one group is systematically deemed inferior. Europeans established their perceived superiority by strategically emphasising their virtues andattributes. The essence of European identity was not one of inclusivity or collaboration with native populations; rather, it was rooted in the desire for dominance and control. Europeansmaintained a sense of seclusion and unabashedly advocated for their lifestyle as the epitome of ideal living. They imposed their worldview onto others through institutionalised methods ofgovernance and socialisation. A parallel can be drawn in the creation of the bourgeois identity in Calcutta, where similar patterns of othering and assertion of superiority are evident.


Image

The Cognizance of Paras

On the contrary, natives were actively shaping the landscape of the city through a social framework known regionally as Para, Tala, or Tuli, which revolved around social relations and powerdynamics. By 1852, the city encompassed 18 paras, illustrating the pervasive influence of this concept in the urban landscape understood by the natives. The para concept has endured over timeand remains deeply ingrained in the oral traditions and understanding of urban spaces. (2) Paras were resilient entities, as the sense of belonging within them was integral to their residents. Theseclusters of neighbourhoods were characterised by homogeneity and were segregated based on factors such as occupation, geographical location, community, or even the name of a tree. Theyconstituted the northern region enclosed within the heterogeneous Circular Road.

In 1817, the formation of the Lottery Commission, comprising indigenous elites, marked a significant development. These commissioners served as the primary representatives of the nativepopulation to the British authorities. Their role involved generating funds for sanitation and other infrastructural projects to be executed by the Town Improvement Committee. Despite theirambitious endeavours, the lottery commissioners faced challenges in persuading the native community to accept developments that would physically divide their paras, even when such projectsoffered fiscal benefits for resident traders (Chattopadhyay, 2005).The paras collectively harmonised like a four-part musical composition, with each part contributing its essence to the whole. Every missing tenor or bass line in this composition left its distinctmark, underscoring the intricate interplay and resilience of these neighborhood clusters within the urban fabric.

Indigenous Elites and their Desire to be ModernThe indigenous elites of Calcutta consist of two distinct categories: landlords and the working middle class, hereinafter referred to as the bourgeois. The working class migrated and settled withinthe city limits following the implementation of the Permanent Settlement Bill in 1973. By the turn of the century, this working class, alongside a middling class comprising professionals such asteachers, lawyers, doctors, and journalists, began to occupy middle to low ranks in the colonial services. In nineteenth-century Bengali discourse, the landed elite was known by various termssuch as Vishayi (propertied), Dhani (wealthy), Abhijata (aristocrats), or Baramanush (literally, "big" people), while the middling classes were referred to as Madhyabitta (middle income) orgrihastha (householder). Together with the "Daridra Athacha Bhadra" (poor yet respectable), they constituted the respectable minority of Bengali residents in the city, known as the Bhadralok(Chattopadhyay, 2005, pp. 138-139).These bourgeois individuals, educated in principles of equality and other modern ideals by their European rulers, aspired to a lifestyle characterised by privacy and independence. Their preferences were reflected in their choices of furniture and the deliberate segregation of spaces based on the hierarchy of activities and the level of privacy associated with each.

Exclusivity in Chowrangee and ParaUntil the mid-18th century, Chowrangee was regarded as the suburbs of Calcutta and was greatly favoured by Europeans. In 1794, the Governor General issued a proclamation delineating thetown's limits between the Hooghly River to the west and the inner side of the Mahratta Ditch to the east, and between Dihee Birjee to the south and the Chitpur nullah (creek) to the north(Chattopadhyay, 2005, p. 79). Chowrangee emerged as an established elite neighbourhood within the city, with many of its land properties owned by Indian landlords. These plots featured servantquarters at the periphery and bungalows in the center, with ample space for the façade. The proximity of the servant quarters to the elite residences was notable, resembling a relative minor to amajor key in music, with the activities of the servants well-defined around the houses (refer to map). Unlike the grand courtyard houses owned by the affluent Indian residents in North Calcutta,these houses in Chowrangee exhibited a heightened sense of privacy while remaining accommodating to their social circles. In contrast, the houses in North Calcutta maintained a degree ofexclusivity within the individual units but were inclusive of the neighbourhood paras. The nature of inclusivity and exclusiveness thus differed significantly between these two areas.

Indigenous Bourgeois intervention into City planningThe indigenous elites of Calcutta comprised two main categories: landlords and the working middle class, hereafter referred to as the bourgeois. The working class migrated from neighbouringvillages and settled within the city limits following the enactment of the Permanent Settlement Bill in 1973. By the turn of the century, these middling professionals, including teachers, lawyers,doctors, and journalists, occupied middle to low ranks in the colonial services. In nineteenth-century Bengali terminology, these landed elites constituted the respectable minority of the Bengaliresidents in the city, known as the Bhadralok.With the examination of exclusivity, it becomes evident that the notion of 'othering' is inherent in both the cases of the English and the bourgeois. Various government bodies involved in thedevelopment of Calcutta, from the Lottery Commission in 1817 to the Calcutta Improvement Trust founded in 1912, have adhered to the practice of segregating certain groups into the 'beyond'.The normalization of segregating housing schemes into categories such as MIG, HIG, LIG, and EWS further perpetuates this practice. As a result, all development schemes from middle-incomegroups to economically weaker sections are typically situated along roads leading to the 'beyond', originating from the Maratha ditch. Responsibilities are transferred akin to the progression of achord, maintaining harmony across scales despite traversing different terrains. "The modernizing aspirations of these elites not only shaped the development agenda of independent India but alsoplayed a crucial role in convincing pioneering planners that the homogeneous neighbourhood unit was an appropriate model for India" (Vidyarthi, 2015). However, the development oftransportation networks that seamlessly traverse the north-south corridor challenges the homogeneity of neighbourhoods and serves as sites of rupture.

Conclusion

This study highlights the enduring presence of perceptual boundaries in Calcutta, akin to those found in any other colonial city. While these boundaries initially existed as abstract concepts, theymaterialized into physical divisions with minimal disruption to the administrative framework. The establishment of homogeneous neighborhoods serves as tangible evidence of the elite'saspirational embrace of colonial ideals. Decisions regarding such developments continue to be made progressively by successive generations of the bourgeois. These creations persistently evoke asense of "beyond" and "within," perpetuating a desire among the elites for spatial demarcations within the urban landscape.

Footnotes 

English visitors to late eighteenth-century and nineteenth-century Calcutta did assert that there was a white town and a black town. The former was represented by the fine rows of housessurrounding the maidan, while its counterpart, the black town, was seemingly situated somewhere beyond. (Chattopadhyay, 2005, p. 77) 

1. 

06/05/2024, 15:00 Csrf - Blogs https://csrf.citistrata.com/csrf-admin/addblog.php 1/2

2. Paras are clusters of residential neighborhoods that is rooted in the sense of community. 

3. “The 1819 will of Joykissen Singh, a banian, shows that he owned Rs. 740,430 of landed property in Calcutta, some of the most expensive of which were in Baranussy Ghose’s Street,Harrington Street, Chowringhee Road, and Clive Street. Even those of middling income considered landed property a worthwhile investment” (Chattopadhyay, 2005).


References

Chattopadhyay, S. (2005). Represting Calcutta - Modernity, nationalism and the colonial uncalnny. Abingdon: Routledge.Deshpande, R. (1939). Modern ideal Homes for India. Pune: United Book Corporation.Mitra, T. (2011). Integrating grey zones in the city fabric a study in transformation of housing dynamics in Kolkata India. Kolkata: Jadavpur University. Retrieved from Shodhganga:https://shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/handle/10603/157389Vidyarthi, S. (2015). One Idea, Many Plans: An American City Design Concept in Independent India. London: Routledge.

Please note that this essay was written as part of studio at CEPT University.